Sunday, March 9, 2014

White water rafters protest building of dam

The White Water Rafting Association of Sri Lanka (WWRASL) yesterday staged a protest at Kitulgala town against the Broadlands Hydro Power Project claiming that it would sound the death knell for their business as there wouldn’t be enough water for sports in the event of the river being dammed.

Hundreds of people engaged in the business and their dependents who participated in the protest sought President Mahinda Rajapaksa’s immediate intervention to solve their problem. Foreign tourists, too, took part in the demonstration as water rafting was not conducted yesterday.

Buddhist monks joined the protest march which commenced from Kalubotenna, three kilometres away from the Kitulgala town. Protesters carried placards with slogans: ‘Don’t kill the river’, ‘Should it be used for power or sports?’, "Dear Mr. President Please protect the white water rafting and communities that depend on it’, ‘No one has a right to destroy the legacy of white water rafting’ and ‘Save the wild and scenic Kelani river.’




Assistant Secretary of the WWRASL I. M. P. Duminda told The Island that they had held several rounds of discussions with the officials of the Ministry of Power and Energy regarding their problem but in vain.

Tourism in the Kithulgala area was based on water rafting and all tourism related businesses were in danger due to the project, he said, adding that sufficient water for rafting could not be maintained the whole day if a dam was build across the river.

"We are not against the project," Duminda said, adding that they could not ask tourists to come during particular hours for the sport as any time of the day was available for them at present.

Spokesman of the Power and Energy Ministry Sisira Wijesinghe, contacted for comment, said that last discussion in this regard had been held last week at the ministry and ministry agreed to look into their grievances.

Wijesinghe said that WWRASL had also agreed to sign an agreement promising sufficient water for their business at the final discussion.

"Economic Development Minister Basil Rajapaksa and subject Minister Pavithra Wanniarachchi inaugurated the project on July 15 last year," Wijesinghe said, noting that there had been no opposition during the last seven months, but there was something behind the sudden protest.

The estimated cost of the 35MW hydro power plant, which would generate 126 million units of power annually, is USD 82 million, of which 85 per cent will be financed by the Chinese Government and the balance by the Sri Lankan government.

The government is to raise 85 per cent of the USD 82 million required for the project from Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) and the remaining 15 per cent from the People’s Bank.

The construction of the hydro power plant has been assigned to the China National Electric Equipment Corporation (CNEEC), which has presented the lowest bid for the project.

Broadlands will be the last plant in the Laxapana complex on the Kelani River. The Project is to be completed by 2017.

Source:http://island.lk/index.php?page_cat=article-details&page=article-details&code_title=99453

Saturday, March 1, 2014

Another little jumbo cruelly snatched and tied up

With only a month since the SundayTimes reported an attempt to snatch a baby elephant from jungles of Galgamuwa, a raid by Wildlife Department officers turned up a little elephant kept illegally on a Mirigama estate, showing elephant poaching is a deep-seated racket.
The baby elephant, suspected to have been caught in the wild, was found on Friday (February 28).
It is illegal to keep any elephant captive without a permit from Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC) and the mahouts failed to submit a credible permit for this baby elephant. Wildlife officers said they had produced a photocopy of a permit given for a six-and-a-half-year-old captive elephant. But this baby elephant is only about two or three years old. In absence of a credible permit the officers took the elephant into their custody.
The young elephant had cut wounds in its leg due to being tightly roped – a sure sign that it was not born to a captive female elephant.
Elephant specialists point out that if this elephant had been born in captivity it would have been accustomed to humans. Such an elephant would easily be tamed and there would be no need for being tightly roped. Cut wounds are caused when the baby elephant that is not used to being restricted is trying to get free.
The raid team was led Assistant Director of Western Wildlife Region W. Indrajith. The baby elephant has been transferred to the Elephant Transit Home (ETH) in Udawalawe. The officials say they are determined to find and arrest the real culprits behind this crime. Only a month ago an attempt to snatch a baby elephant from jungles of Galgamuwa was thwarted by the vigilance of villagers. The existence of a racket of snatching baby elephants to be raised in captivity has been known since late 1990s but due to involvement of powerful forces the real culprits continually escape being put behind bars.
It is believed as many as 60 elephants illegally caught from the wild are in hands of private owners.
At Mirigama the raising team found another grown elephant aged over 10 years for which the owners could not produce a permit. They stationed a guard at the estate asking the owners to submit the permit for this elephant. If the owner does not give a satisfactory response the DWC will this elephant also into safekeeping. The head of the DWC, H.D. Ratnayake, said his department would not hesitate to make any arrest if proper evidence is submitted.
Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/140302/news/another-little-jumbo-cruelly-snatched-and-tied-up-87554.html

Saturday, February 15, 2014

Biopiracy on the rise

In the space of a week, two attempts by overseas visitors to smuggle out local flora and fauna were foiled. A German national and four Russians were apprehended for collecting indigenous wild plants and animals without a permit. Environmentalists say Sri Lanka’s rich and unique biodiversity has been attracting outside interest for some time.

Last Saturday, February 9, members of the Wildlife Conservation Society of Galle (WCSG) spotted four foreigners behaving in a suspicious way in the jungle of Hiyare, in Galle. Hiyare is a nature reserve and a “hotspot” for biodiversity. The Galle nature lovers informed the Hikkaduwa office of the Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC), which dispatched a team of wildlife officers. The Russians had in their possession an amphibian and a clutch of rare land snails. They were produced in court and fined Rs. 300,000.


The confiscated land snails belong to the Acavus species. Fluid extracted from this snail is used in medication for asthma-related problems, according to WCSG president Madhura de Silva. The Russians could have been collecting the snail species for pharmaceutical research, he said. Tropical countries are a popular target for bio-pirates, said Mr. de Silva, adding that this was not the first time Russians were detected prowling in Hiyare.
Last year, the Wildlife Conservation Society of Galle surprised another group of Russian visitors combing the jungle for biological treasures. By the time wildlife officers arrived on the scene, the Russians had disappeared. The Wildlife Conservation Society traced the Russians to their hotel, but the hotel management would not allow them to search the Russians. It was later revealed that the Russians were looking for Spray Beetles, which eject a toxic chemical to repel natural enemies. This chemical too, Mr. de Silva said, could be useful for pharmaceutical research.
The second case of bio-piracy was reported from Agalawatte, in the Kalutara disctrict. Forest officers accosted a German national collecting rare water plants in the jungle of Runakanda. Some of the plants are indigenous to Sri Lanka. Ingiriya Range Forest Officer H. M. A. B. Herath said the visitor, a scientist, was carrying information about a rare water plant, Cryptocoryne bogneri, or water trumpet. The visitor claimed to be a member of a scientific organisation called the “Cryptocoryne Society of Germany”, and that he was collecting material for scientific purposes. It was found that the German had visited the same forest in 2008. He was carrying documents and instruments giving exact GPS locations, PH meters, maps and research papers. Cryptocoryne bogneri is a “critically endangered” plant species, and specimens have been rare in recent years.
Last November, Mr. Herath arrested a Russian couple who were collecting orchids in the Sinharaja rainforest. The visitors had amassed more than 300 orchid plants of 32 species from different parts of the country. The plants included one “critically endangered” species and 11 “endangered species.”
The number of arrests of foreigners caught plundering local flora and fauna is on the rise. In addition to the above incidents, there have been other cases this year, including a group of Bangladeshis who were caught with the medicinal plant “walla patta”, or Gyrinops walla, which produces an agarwood resin that is used in the manufacture of expensive perfumes, and a team of Hungarians who were chasing butterflies in Sigiriya.
Environmentalists say overseas visitors have different motives for collecting animals and plants. Some are genuine scientists with a passion for knowledge about exotic plants and animals; some are looking for commercial gain; some want to study the specimens and then release them back into the wild; and some hope to skip the trouble of getting permits from the Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC). Fortunately, there are vigilant local environment lovers who have are bringing bio-pirates to book.
Not all foreigners scouring the countryside for flora and fauna species are bio-pirates. Last year, a group of foreigners was reported to be illegally collecting Horned Lizards in the Knuckles mountain range, but the Sunday Times found that the foreigners were scientists on legitimate research, and had the support of the University of Peradeniya.
Those arrested for wildlife crime usually say they were not aware that they were breaking the law.

“Every tourist should know to respect a country’s laws,” says Vipula Wanigasekare of the Sri Lanka Conventions Bureau, a division of Sri Lanka Tourism. “Saying you didn’t know the law is no excuse. Brochures to educate tourists on what is legal and not legal are readily available. In general, visitors are respectful of the country and happy to protect what is ours, including our biodiversity.”
The Wildlife Department says it will be putting up information boards at the Bandaranaike International Airport spelling out wildlife and environment regulations for the benefit of tourists.

Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/130224/news/biopiracy-on-the-rise-34295.html

Lanka’s perfume goldmine

Walla Patta, scientifically known as Gyrinops walla, is a commonly seen sub canopy tree that grows in home gardens as well as in wet zone forests. So it came as a surprise when authorities learned of illicit operations to smuggle this seemingly insignificant tree out of the country.
Not long ago, Walla Patta was found to produce a resinous substance called “Agarwood” (also known as oud), which is used as a base for the world’s most expensive perfumes. No one in Sri Lanka knew Walla Patta had this valuable property until recently.
“Agarwood specialists haven’t had a chance to study Walla Patta,” Dr. Samantha S. Fernando, biodiversity specialist and researcher attached to the University of Peradeniya, told the Sunday Times. “International specialists say they don’t know if Walla Patta can actually produce Agarwood, they haven’t even seen the plant. Even scientists and law enforcement officials didn’t know about this, but the smugglers knew. ”
A Walla Patta smuggling operation was apprehended “for the first time in history” in Kalawana, Ratnapura, earlier this year, by a rainforest officer who saw Indian men carrying bags of wood chips. A follow-up investigation revealed the smugglers were using the wood to extract Agarwood
.
In the latest bust, Norton Bridge police arrested eight people including an Indonesian national for illicitly felling and transporting Walla Patta. Norton Bridge Police OIC Bandara Devatagedara said the arrestees had with them two tins of perfume oil with pictorial labels depicting the Walla Patta tree.
“The Indonesian knew how to take the important parts of the tree,” Inspector Devatagedara said. “Our people didn’t know. He had even brought special knives and equipment to extract Agarwood from the trees.”
“Authorities are still investigating the scale of these smuggling operations. Smugglers are believed to sneak Agarwood out of the country hidden with other products such as palm oil,” the inspector said.
Walla Patta is not protected under the Fauna and Flora Protection Ordinance, but cannot be taken out of the country without permission.
“Because Walla Patta has indigenous medicinal properties, to allow sustainable use, the tree is not protected under Section 42 of the Ordinance,” Environmental Lawyer Jagath Gunawardena said. “But under the Forest Conservation Ordinance, any part of a tree growing in a forest is ‘forest produce,’ and cannot be felled, collected, transported, kept in possession or exported in any form without permission from Forest Conservation Department.”
Walla Patta is listed in Appendix II of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), and therefore, cannot be taken out of the country without a CITES permit, Mr. Gunawardena added.
Forest Conservator General K.B. Ariyadasa said the Forest Conservation Department had banned Walla Patta felling and exports.
“Now we have banned Walla Patta felling in protected areas,” he said. “But they continue in private lands. Right now, we don’t allow exports either, even from private lands. We need to continue investigations into the value and uses of this plant.”
Smuggling reveals the true value of Walla Patta
“Agarwood is traditionally extracted from plants in the genus Aquilaria. There are about 15 plants in this genus that can produce Agarwood, mostly in countries such as Indonesia, Malaysia and China,” Dr. Fernando said.
Agarwood is formed when the trunk and roots of a mature Aquilaria tree is infected with a parasitic fungus. The infected tree excretes a resin to fight off the fungus, which darkens and solidifies in the heartwood of the tree, and is called Agarwood. Once extracted and processed into oil, it’s known to emanate a “sweet, deep but balanced” fragrance. Due to its alcohol-free status, Agarwood oil and perfumes are highly prized by Middle Easterners.
The genus Aquilaria is not found in Sri Lanka. However, there’s another genus called Gyrinops, also used to produce Agarwood, but not as popularly, and Walla Patta belongs to this genus.
“Historically, it wasn’t known that we could make Agarwood from Gyrinops plants in Sri Lanka,” Dr. Fernando said. “It was never recorded that we could make Agarwood, if we had known, we would have also made it.”
“Locals mostly use Walla Patta for bark fibre ropes for limb casts or “patta baedeema,” and as medicine for serpent stings, toothaches and so on,” Peradeniya Botanical Gardens Director General Siril Wijesundara said. Most locals are ignorant of the commercial value of the product and the nature of Agarwood.
“Some villagers came to us and said some ‘misled’ foreigners paid them for infected (‘una baessa’) Walla Patta trees,” Dr. Fernando said. “They think Rs 500 or Rs 1,000 is good money for a tree that’s not even healthy.”
“In fact, world market prices for Agarwood goes up to US$ 60,000 (about Rs 7,700,000) per kilo for first grade products and US$ 25,000 per kilo for third grade products,” Mr. Gunawardena said. The exact value of Agarwood extracted from Walla Patta is yet to be determined.
“Currently, the most valuable resin in the market is Aquilaria malaccensis,” Dr. Fernando said. “We don’t know if Walla Patta is more valuable. It’s like our universities and government bodies are searching in the dark.”
There’s only one known published scientific study on the subject; “Agarwood-type Resin from Gyrinops walla Gaertn: A New Discovery,” conducted by University of Sri Jayawardenapura Professor Upul Subasinghe and colleagues. The study compared resin from Walla Patta against commercially available Aquilaria resin and concluded that major compounds from Aquilaria Agarwood is also present in Walla Patta Agarwood.
“The compounds may be present in different percentages, but they are there,” Dr. Subasinghe said. “Therefore, there is a similarity, but we need to do more research with high tech equipment.”
Dr. Subasinghe, with an academic background in ecology, suspected Agarwood properties of Walla Patta as the plant belonged to the Agarwood-producing family. He thought he was the first to know, until he heard about smuggling operations from people in Balangoda and Kalutara.
“Regarding smuggling, my gut feeling is that they may mix Walla Patta resin with foreign products and sell it for low prices,” Dr. Subasinghe said. “This has a huge value in the open market, if we can prove Walla Patta resin value with further research based on similarities, the government could cultivate this on a major scale like rubber. As scientists we can only suggest.”
In other countries, there are Aquilaria plantations and farmers artificially inoculate the tree to make Agarwood. Mr. Ariyadasa said, cultivation in Sri Lanka for commercial purposes is also possible with more research. Dr. Fernando said there is much to be known before commercial cultivation, such as the type of fungus that the tree reacts against and how to artificially inoculate to produce the same results.
“Honestly, this is like a gold mine for Sri Lanka,” Dr. Fernando said. “First, we need to stop the smuggling, otherwise the trees won’t remain for research. This will be a good source of income from our rich biodiversity, and will be more environmentally sustainable than growing tea in the wet zone. Also, we need to claim patent rights for Walla Patta Agarwood before other countries do. We have a good defence, as Gyrinops walla (called after the plant’s Sinhala name) was first recorded in Galle in 1780 by J.G. Konig.”
Gold mine threatened
“Because of the recently discovered monetary value of Walla Patta trees, combined with the general lack of knowledge, unnecessary felling of the tree has increased. Most people don’t understand healthy trees have no commercial value, but cut them down, hoping to sell them anyway,” Mr. Ariyadasa said.
In addition, the infection occurs inside the bark of the tree, therefore, some cut the trees just to check for infection.
“The tree is not in the endangered situation, but the threat still exists, as word has spread that Walla Patta is valuable,” Mr. Ariyadasa said. “Few know about Agarwood. The infection occurs in only about 10% or 15% of trees, so we need to advise people against unnecessary felling,”
Dr. Fernando said there are no proper governmental safeguards for the tree, considering its enormous value.
“There’s a saying that Agarwood is worth more than gold,” he added. “So, it’s still worthwhile for the smugglers to pay our minuscule fine for violating the law, and still illegally export. It’s that valuable. These operations have been going on for six or seven years.
We need to take immediate steps to protect this plant. But government bodies work slower than most; by the time they go from one meeting to another, smugglers have taken the plant out of the country.”
Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/121209/news/lankas-perfume-goldmine-23702.html

Wallapatta agarwood the new illegal million-rupee racket

An attempt to smuggle out wallapatta agarwood worth Rs. 12 million was prevented by vigilant Customs officers last week.
The offender had 16.8kg of the substance concealed in his baggage, Samantha Gunasekara of the Customs Biodiversity Protection Unit said. It had been cleaned and considered to be grade 1 quality.
The offender was at Bandaranaike International Airport to board a Bangalore-bound flight. Preliminary investigations revealed that he was only a carrier, and investigations are underway to find the source of the agarwood.
Agarwood is a product of the wild tree, wallapatta, and it is illegal to own or take out a forest product without permission but because of its high value criminals collect and export it illegally.
Wallapatta is scientifically classified as a sub-canopy tree growing in wet zone forests as well as in home gardens in these areas. The tree creates a resin called agarwood in its core as a reaction to a fungal infection, and this is used as a base for perfumes.
Perfumes produced using agarwood are expensive because of the resin’s scarcity, so a wave of illegal felling of wallapatta has been reported, several dozen cases from different parts of Sri Lanka in the first weeks of 2014.
In the latest case, Morontuduwa police arrested three men for cutting down a wallapatta tree and transporting in a van. Because the agarwood has to be exported illegally, stringent measures have to be put in place to nab the offenders who mastermind this racket.
Only some wallapatta trees affected by fungi manufacture the agarwood resin. Since there is no way to detect whether a wallapatta tree is secreting agarwood, trees are being felled indiscriminately for quick profits.
Prof. Nimal Gunatilleke, who has studied the growth of wallapatta, warns that extensive removal of large mature trees could affect the survival of wild wallapatta trees, already categorised as “vulnerable” to extinction on the National RedList.
Prof. Gunatilleke points out that investigation of the tree’s reproductive ecology and low-cost propagation methods of wallapatta were needed to restore the growth of the tree in the forest and to increase domestic growth to reduce pressure on this rapidly dwindling natural resource.
The Director General of the Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC) said regulations to protect wallapatta have been drafted. He said the cultivation of wallapatta would be encouraged under stringent monitoring conditions.
Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/140216/news/wallapatta-agarwood-the-new-illegal-million-rupee-racket-85990.html

Saturday, April 20, 2013

In the wilds among men counting elephants


After a long bumpy ride to the heart of the Minneriya National Park, we saw hundreds of them – adults, sub-adults, juveniles and calves – lumbering towards a water-hole. The two observers of the Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC) quickly started counting and making note of the number of elephants.
The observers had spotted 187 elephants at the waterhole from 6 a.m. till noon on the second day of the islandwide elephant census conducted by the Department of Wild Life Conservation. “We can’t be sure of the count. But, I don’t think I will make an error as elephants are not new to me,” said one observer. Elephant surveys are usually conducted during the peak drought period. In this method, known as the waterhole count, elephants are counted when they go in large numbers to big water- holes. The smaller waterholes dry up during the drought.


A man takes down data as elephants gather at the water-hole in Minneriya


The islandwide census which was a 48-hour survey from 6 p.m on Thursday to 6 p.m. on Saturday was the first of its kind in the country. There were 1,553 observation points islandwide and upto 4,000 observers – wildlife department officials, volunteers and military personnel participated in the programme, DWC Deputy Director S.R.B. Dissanayake, said.
He said, volunteers and military men were given a training on how to conduct the census. In some areas villagers and civil defence forces also assisted the department officials, he said. The observers with pencil and sheet of paper in hand marked the location where the elephants were sighted, the time, category and male-female ratio.
DWC official W.B.M. Wijesiri said although the animals did not pose a threat unless they were disturbed, the observers carried a shotgun for safety. He said, one of the main classification of the jumbos was gender and to do this they observed their shapes. “While female elephants have straight and flat backs, the males have rounded backs,” he said.
However, counting and categorising the large number of elephants from the observation points, which are quite a distance away from the animals can give rise to inaccuracies. Our own count on the number of elephants near the lake was more than 400. Moreover, we noticed baby elephants hiding behind their parents and this would have posed a big problem for the observers.
Observers perchd on an observation post await the arrival of elephants

Commenting on our query about accuracy, the Deputy Director, Mr. Dissanayake said, if the observers are trained properly, precision can be ensured. “We are not counting the elephants one by one, this is more a survey. More than the numbers, we are collecting information on the population structure of the elephants - proportion of calves, adults and the percentage of juveniles,” he said.
As I was speaking to Mr. Dissanayake he suddenly yelled ‘run’. An elephant was charging towards the area where our jeeps were stopped, where photographers were clicking pictures and we were talking to the Deputy Director.
We jumped into the closest jeep and beat a hasty retreat. After following the convoy of jeeps for about 90 seconds, the jumbo gave up. Wild Life officials told us that the elephant had lost its young recently and hence the reason for its aggressiveness.
Mr. Dissanayake said another aspect of the survey was to find out how healthy the elephant population was. Based on the results, the DWC hopes to cordon off more protection zones for the elephants. He also said to curb the human-elephant conflict in unprotected areas, electrified fences will be put up to protect the villagers and their fields, he added.
However some scientists question the accuracy of the waterhole method. A wildlife biologist, who did not want to be identified, said this method of census was used in India several times but had been proved a failure. “The census is not scientifically sound. You can’t cover every waterhole.”
The biologist said that most elephants are found outside national parks and come out at night, but, this survey concentrated on the interior of the parks. Elaborating that this method was more assumption-based, the scientist said there was no guarantee that all the elephants would come to the waterholes. Moreover, Minneriya is a place where elephants can be spotted easily, whereas, there are several other places where the elephants do not come out to the waterholes.
How many calves hiding behind their elders may have been left out in the census? Pix by Sanka Vidanagama and Kanchana Kumara Ariyadasa
“I believe the census is pointless. One should concentrate on unknown areas. Scientists pulled out from the census because of the methodology. There are thousands of waterholes in the South and the Central areas and you can’t man every one of them,” he said.
The biologist pointed out that the elephants that were counted in Minneriya may even go towards the Kaudulla National Park, which is just a few kilometres away, thereby increasing the chances of being counted twice over.
As quick-fix methods, such as the waterhole counts, are not accurate, technical methods need to be implemented. However, the latter requires a high degree of training, skill, expertise, funds, time and dedication, according to him.
Meanwhile, Wild Life minister S.M. Chandrasena told a news conference at Minneriya on Friday, that the aim of the census was to get an idea of the number of elephants in the country.“We don’t have a special reason to count tuskers. People say we are going to give away some tuskers. I can't handover tuskers to anyone as I wish. And, I don't want to,” Mr. Chandrasena said.


He said, he wanted to ensure that the country’s wildlife was protected adding that the elephants used for Peraheras (pageants) are from the Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage and not from the wild. Reacting to the minister’s statement, Environmental lawyer Jagath Gunawardena said he was glad that the minister had changed his decision about the tuskers.
He said although they wanted to participate in the census, they pulled out on a matter of principle.
Mr. Gunawardena said partial surveys conducted earlier have revealed that 60 per cent of elephants were old, whereas, it shouldn’t be more than 40 per cent while juveniles and sub-adults constitute half the population.

Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/110814/News/nws_14.html


Conflict over jumbo census


  • Water-hole count enables population structure and composition assessment:DWC
  • Extent of occurrence, area of occupancy more relevant, says expert
By Kumudini Hettiarachchi
Futile and flawed, are how many experts called the much-trumpeted “elephant survey” carried out by the Department of Wildlife Conservation (DWC) which ended this morning. The danger of a flawed survey lies in the fact that it may be used as a planning tool for elephant management which in turn would then be questionable, stressed wildlife biologist Manori Gunawardena, explaining that the survey methodology does not take into account elephant behaviour.
Pointing out that although the elephants at Minneriya are very visible during the day, most elephants outside National Parks come out only in the night, she says that it is “very difficult to count them”.
Ms. Gunawardena should know as she has been studying the social behaviour and demography of elephants in the North Central Province for the past 12 years, getting muddy and grubby at many a waterhole including the Minneriya tank.


The DWC, however, claims in its ‘Survey of Elephants in Sri Lanka’ leaflet that its current venture is “known as the water-hole count”. The advantage of the water-hole count is that it enables the management authority to find out the population structure and composition in addition to numbers, according to the DWC.
“It will enable the DWC to determine the proportion of calves relative to the adult females and to identify and record the number of tuskers – the most vulnerable animals.”
Unless there is much practice and training and there are only one or two elephants it is impossible to put them into an “age class” or “size class”, says Ms. Gunawardena, citing the example of elephant herds coming to water at one point of a tank and then cutting across the forest later to get back to the water at a different point of the same tank. “Elephants keep crisscrossing all the time,” she said.
At Minneriya there may be high visibility and excellent observation conditions but take the case of a wewa outside the National Parks. Would it be possible to count a large number at night in the moonlight, and especially when they keep coming back to water, she asks, adding that a survey done without taking into account elephant behaviour movement is flawed.


Scientists also question the rationale of such a survey effort, when the concentration should be on identifying key areas that need conservation. An island-wide survey of elephant distribution and human-elephant conflict would be more relevant for management purposes, they say. Conservationists expressed fear that the survey was done to fulfil hidden agendas that are detrimental to conservation.
The Indian scientific community, meanwhile, has urged Sri Lanka not to get entrenched in the “water-hole count” methodology as they are desperate to dislodge it from government practice across there as it has failed, sources pointed out.
The Sunday Times learns that, the Co-Chairman of the IUCN Asian Elephant Specialist Group, Ajay A. Desai has expressed reservations about the water-hole count to many conservationists in Sri Lanka.
“Population estimation is best done using the most standardized methods i.e. line transect or dung count,” Dr. Desai has said in an e-mail, being extremely critical of “pointless and questionable methods” such as water-hole counts which have been tried and found to be failures in India. He has wondered why Sri Lanka is repeating the mistakes made by India.
Meanwhile, back in 2008 in ‘Gajah’, the Journal of the Asian Elephant Specialist Group (available online at http://www.asesg.org/ PDFfiles/Gajah%2028% 20Aug%2008.pdf), another elephant expert Dr. Prithiviraj Fernando had questioned the need to get the “number” of elephants in a country, region or for that matter globally.
Why do we need to know the ‘number’, Dr. Fernando of the Centre for Conservation and Research has questioned, explaining that as Asian elephants live in low visibility habitats and are secretive and largely nocturnal, the numbers are elusive. He also questions how we can use the ‘number’ to plan conservation strategies.



“Can we determine a-priori how many elephants we want to have in a country, will we cull them if there are more, or can we ask them to breed more if there are fewer?” he asked. Dr. Fernando who has been in the jungles, studying elephants for over 18 years states that counting of elephants is done in various ways that range from ‘quick and dirty’ to highly technical. It could be direct aerial, vehicle, foot and waterhole counts of elephants; indirect estimates based on sign, dung and footprints; and individual identification based on genetics or photography and mark-capture or rarefaction curves.
He states that counts are probably of value at local scales, for planning and monitoring the impact of management activities. However, it needs accuracy and precision, he cautions, warning that “unfortunately, the quick and dirty methods are neither accurate nor precise, so we have to rely on the more technical methods. These require a high degree of training, skill, expertise, funds, time and dedication.”
Dr. Fernando suggests that IUCN criteria such as ‘extent of occurrence’ and ‘area of occupancy’ are more relevant for management at country-wide scales than the elusive ‘number’. Around 4,000 people including 1,200 DWC staff undertook the survey after being stationed at “1,553 points” in the seven wildlife regions on the night of August 11, said a DWC spokesperson.
Each point was manned by a wildlife officer and two others or a wildlife officer and one other, who were on attala (platforms in trees) or close to the waterhole, armed with binoculars, a DWC spokesperson said, explaining that those who helped with the survey included students from the Rajarata and Peradeniya Universities, recruits from the Civil Defence Force and villagers in the area. In the north, the survey was carried out by DWC officials and soldiers.
The seven regions are north-western (Kurunegala, Puttalam, Anuradhapura and Vavuniya); Mahaweli (Polonnaruwa, Trincomalee, parts of Matale and Badulla); central; east; southern; Yala-Bundala; and north.
Referring to the modus operandi followed, the spokesperson said, on Thursday night they observed the elephants which came to the water-holes and the count proper began on Friday and Saturday, with the operation winding down this morning.
When asked whether there was the likelihood of one elephant being counted twice or more times, the spokesperson said it was unlikely. Those doing the survey were well-versed in taking down the vishesha lakshana (special features) and identifying each elephant from the shape of the ear, the placement of pigmentation (gomera), the tail details etc.
However, as most elephants come to water in the night, the practicality of this was questioned by scientists. “Many thousands of watering points are used by elephants including large reservoirs with perimeters of many tens of kilometres, rivers and streams which cannot be manned adequately,” a source said.
Another pointed out that the number of elephants counted will be proportional to the number of points as most enumerators will feel compelled to report that they saw some elephants. Many teams were deployed at points where large numbers of elephants were known to gather like Minneriya - Kaudulla, the spokesperson said, when the Sunday Times asked how 400 elephants could be counted when they converged on the tank-bed at the same time.
Queried why the teams have been tasked with noting the detailed description of the elephants’ tusks, the spokesperson said it was nothing new. The same document had been used in the 2008 survey in the Mahaweli region. All the survey data will be analyzed to formulate a conservation strategy, the spokesperson added.

One of the pages of the document used by officers conducting the census

Rs. 23 million from Wildlife Fund; 2000 bags from Florida centre
The Cabinet approved Rs. 23 million from the DWC’s Wildlife Fund for the ‘Survey of Elephants in Sri Lanka’ while a hotel chain forked out Rs. 1.8 million for the counting in the Yala area, the Sunday Times learns from the DWC.
An interesting “input”, confirmed by the DWC, was the provision of 2,000 bags for those involved in the counting by Bruce Read of the Ringling Center for Elephant Conservation in Florida, America.
A web search shows amidst all the propaganda material about “caring for Asian elephants” that the Ringling Bros. Center is largely an elephant breeding centre that provides baby elephants for circuses. Incidentally, the Ringling Bros. Center also boasts on its website that among the experts from around the world who visit it are Dr. Raman Sukumar and Dr. Charles Santiapillai, a long-time collaborator of Bruce Read.
Both Dr. Santiapillai linked to the Peradeniya University and Dr. Sukumar from India have been associated with the survey, DWC sources said.

Source:http://www.sundaytimes.lk/110814/News/nws_13.html